NGADM 2014 Group Round - More Stats!

2014-08-26 16:44:52 by etherealwinds
Updated

I thought I'd provide some more stats for the Group Round of the NGADM 2014. I remember somebody created a ranking list last year that I always found pretty useful. Those in bold are the winners of each group.

I've also averaged out each judges' score to find the strictest and the kindest scoring judge for the group rounds.

Just out interest y'know. Here you go!

Group Round - Rankings
1) Bosa + Kor-Rune - 9.12
2) etherealwinds - 9.03
3) DamienFleisch - 8.97
4) garlagan - 8.93
5) ZipZipper + steampianist - 8.79
6) SoundChris + Hitokirito - 8.77
7) SkyeWint + camoshark - 8.63
8) introstalge - 8.61
9) SilverPoyozo - 8.53
10) Sequenced - 8.48
11) Acid-Paradox - 8.47
12) johnfn - 8.46
12) CoredxBitch - 8.46
14) JacobCadmus - 8.43
15) PirateCrab - 8.32
16) SolarexMusic - 8.28
17) Cross666 - 8.275
18) LunyAlex - 8.25
19) papkee - 8.2
20) JDawg00100 - 8.19
21) Spadezer - 8.18
22) AeronMusic - 8.08
23) RetromanOMG - 8.06
24) PeterSatera - 7.94
25) Pandasticality - 7.91
26) DuttonsaysHi - 7.9
27) Troisnyx - 7.82
28) InvisibleObserver - 7.81
29) ChronoNomad - 7.72
30) Basset-Hound - 7.67
30) Phonometrologist - 7.67
32) IglicaV - 7.66
33) JimmyPig - 7.65
34) SonicWombat - 7.63
34) dexarson - 7.63
36) TheBenjerman - 7.62
37) Kabalist - 7.6
37) Nimble - 7.6
39) Jay-Turner - 7.58
40) Mawnz - 7.53
40) Veneox - 7.53
41) KatMaestro + JRob - 7.4
41) SourJovis - 7.4
44) TetratonMusic - 7.37
45) larrylarrybb - 7.34
46) Azhthar - 7.29
47) Metallica1136 - 7.28
48) secantwave - 7.26
49) Chemiqals - 7.23
50) TosmatoBeef - 7.1
51) BrainLight - 7.01
52) Ceevro - 6.95
53) LunacyEcho - 6.76
54) Jernemies - 6.73
55) MrStr8face - 6.68
56) PascalPalomino - 6.6
57) Guylee - 6.51
58) Braiton - 6.475
59) soulblud - 5.98
60) Cimba - 5.17
61) FlaggedOnArrival - 4.62

(Disqualified:
acmeDyne
MattBat27
TheMoebiusProject)

I've averaged up each judge's scoring for every track submitted in the group rounds and come up with the total score awarded and the average score for each judge.

The judges are in order of the most pussycat and the Simon Cowell of the panel this round.

Judges' Average Scoring:
 

Step - 
Total points awarded: 506.8 
Average score: 8.31


headphoamz
Total points awarded: 488.2
Average score: 8


MetalRenard
Total points awarded: 462
Average score: 7.57


Neon-Bard
Total points awarded: 454.75
Average score: 7.45


midimachine
Total points awarded: 451.22
Average score: 7.4


samulis
Total points awarded: 450.7
Average score: 7.39

Hopefully the extra stats are either helpful or at least of interest to those curious! If anybody notices any mistakes then let me know.

*~ Roll on Round 2! ~*


Comments

You must be logged in to comment on this post.


camosharkcamoshark

2014-08-26 17:02:00

Very nice read, lots of interesting stats.

Thanks for doing this! :)

etherealwinds responds:

You sweetie.


larrynachoslarrynachos

2014-08-26 17:20:22

An average score of 9 is insane!

(My entry for the NGAUC got a 7, so I didn't make it to the finals)

Really good work!

etherealwinds responds:

The average scores of most people were, as I remember, significantly lower than last year's NGADM. Not so many 9+ scores this round.


EvilRaccoonEvilRaccoon

2014-08-26 18:58:42

You were second!? And im second from the bottom of winners. Hows' that fair! :P

You're gonna come at me with everything you got...arent you. FFFFFF!!!! ****
Thanks for the list!

P.S.
FFFFFFFFFF!

etherealwinds responds:

You sir are going to come at me in full force and you're going to produce something amazing. Like a missile. ¬_¬


TroisnyxTroisnyx

2014-08-26 19:00:04

@PeterSatera I'M second to last, not you.


gadogrygadogry

2014-08-26 19:38:36

Hey... you told me in a comment last year that you aren't a math person! And then you did this!

I actually ran the spreadsheet again this year -- the averages I got for the judges disagree with yours by some decimal points but nothing significant. And I didn't find enough interesting things to warrant me doing a post like I did last year (i.e. none of the judges were particularly more impactful than others, they mostly moderately agree on things, etc).

One thing that I thought was noteworthy is that we now have 6 "undeserving" losers (i.e. scores in the top 16 but not advancing). A contest of such format (64 grouped into 16 groups of 4, top score in each group adanvces) should expect 4.9 such casualties if the groups are completely assigned at random. So... 6 is a tad high but not way out of whack.

I've been travelling and don't have time to listen to all the tracks yet. I can't wait to listen to yours since I now know for a fact that it's good :)

etherealwinds responds:

You have an insanely good memory. I rounded some of the scores for the sake of, well, looking more like scores. ^ ^ I hope you've travelled somewhere nice sir!


midimachinemidimachine

2014-08-26 20:16:40

the SD of each judge's score is pretty even too, all between 1.2 and 1.5 iirc

i wanted to do inferential stats but it turns out that only metalrenard's scores had a normal distribution (shapiro-wilk, p = 0.091)

etherealwinds responds:

i like pasta


midimachinemidimachine

2014-08-26 20:39:22

standard deviation m8! cant report means without SDs
soz for being a nerd tho

etherealwinds responds:

hugs 4eva


Neon-BardNeon-Bard

2014-08-27 07:16:36

Samulis = Simon Cowell. Hehehehehe!

Thanks for the stats! ^_^

etherealwinds responds:

Welcome!


LunacyEchoLunacyEcho

2014-09-04 06:47:47

Thanks for doing this! It's really comprehensive and must've taken a lot of work. One thing, though: Shouldn't KatMaestro+JRob and SourJovis be in 42nd place, not 41st?

etherealwinds responds:

<3 It's okay. I wasn't really sure how to structure two pairs of ties one after the other. :)